Farragut weighs TSW contract
The Board plans to decide whether to terminate TSW's services at its Thursday, Dec. 10, meeting.
“We’re not voting to terminate tonight,” North Ward Alderman Joey Ruffalo clarified. “We’re voting to bring the termination letter to the Board, then at the next meeting, we would decide whether or not to proceed.”
Vice Mayor Greg Wiberley made the motion, seconded by North Ward Alderman Larry Segrest, who added an amendment directing TSW to provide the Town with all the study data it has collected so far on the project.
For the Dec. 10 meeting, “can we bring back how much we would have wasted on this?” asked South Ward Alderman Drew Burnette, who cast the lone vote against the motion.
“We can certainly give you the contract numbers of what we’ve spent so far,” Town administrator David Smoak replied.
Three Board members expressed disappointment with the first proposed master plan for the 70-acre McFee Road park property, presented by Tunnell, Spangler, Walsh & Associates, known as TSW, at an Oct. 22 public meeting at McFee Park.
“There are concerns that citizen concerns are not being taken seriously,” Wiberley said. “The design is more urban than natural, which ignores what the majority of citizens want for that land.
“So, I think it’s worth discussing on whether we should proceed down this path we’re going or do something different,” he added.
Bob Greenshields, a resident whose property is adjacent to the park property, said he wants to see the park remain natural and the forest preserved. He suggested placing the road near the railroad tracks and locating any park buildings away from residential homes.
Another resident, Kimberlie Parks, said the Town does not need a master plan for the park.
“I can say, when we had that meeting at McFee [Park] with the residents and [TSW] put their first concept out there, I was really surprised at it,” Mayor Alex Cain said.
“I don’t think the consultant really took into account any of what the people wanted,” he said. “I think maybe we need to discuss a different path on how we’re going to do this.”
Ruffalo added that the amenities “were not discussed at any of the meetings I went to.
“If we can wait, if we don’t have to do anything, we can leave it more nature right now …,” he added.
Although Ruffalo favors having a master plan, he questioned at what point the Board should hold TSW responsible for responding to the Town’s wishes.
However, Burnette defended the consultants and reminded Board members that what TSW presented was only its first concept and was subject to change.
“We are jumping on a team at the beginning of this process,” he said. “You all are wanting the end result. That’s not how this works. You have five, 10 iterations of a project.”
Town attorney Tom
Hale defended the park purchase, saying, “This is probably one of the better deals that has ever been put together by the Town.”
However, Wiberley said the purchase was not presented as a future urban park but as a natural one.
One of the biggest criticisms of the proposed concept is a road planned through the park.
As part of the purchase, the Town agreed to provide a 50-foot roadway easement through the park from McFee Road to the western boundary to provide vehicular access to adjacent privately owned land, according to Wiberley.
“The easement was to be included in the design of the master plan that was to be developed by the Town at a later date by its contractor,” he added.
As currently designed, “it would be heavily used if a housing development was put behind it, and there would be limited ability by the Town to mitigate speeding … and to restrict access to the park,” Wiberley said, adding that it also would expose park users, especially children, to traffic.
“The thing that stuck out to me was that road went right through the middle of [the park] and that it was going to connect to eventually, possibly [a development] in Loudon County,” Cain said. “When I talked to the consultant about it, it fell on deaf ears.
“Since that meeting, I’ve received 38 emails from that area,” the mayor said, adding that residents wanted “a lot of nature.”
While Burnette said he also wanted the road on the south side of the property, he was told, “It’s coming … it takes time.”
“I think it is a grave error not doing anything,” he said. “I think not doing a master plan hurts the Town, hurts the residents and it puts us in a terrible spot.
“One, we want to have full control over where the road goes,” Burnette said.
“We don’t have to do anything right this moment, but at some point, we will have to have a master plan that will provide a place where we want to put our road,” Hale agreed.
Secondly, “we want our parks and our Town to get every single grant we can get … you cannot do the vast majority of these grants [without a master plan],” Burnette said.
“We don’t have to do anything,” Segrest said. “I don’t think TSW has done what they said they were going to do, what they’re supposed to do, which is take our input.”


