Legal review sparks debate in Farragut
Farragut Board of Mayor and Aldermen is looking to put out a request for qualifications for a town attorney.
Following a motion by Mayor Alex Cain, the Board voted 3-2 to direct staff to begin the request for qualifications (RFQ) process for the town attorney contract.
“It doesn’t make sense to me,” said South Ward Alderman Drew Burnette, who voted against the motion along with Alderman Joey Ruffalo. “Redoing everything, to me, seems like it could be a huge waste of money and time without specific drivers for those changes.”
Meanwhile, Vice Mayor Greg Wiberley, Alderman Larry Segrest and Cain voted in favor of the motion.
“This is something that has never been done in the Town since 1980,” said Cain, who added he had talked with the Tennessee Municipal Technical Advisory Service about the issue. “When I came on board, I asked David [Smoak, town administrator], and I had many discussions about it.
“And I’d like to see what’s out there, what’s available from different law firms, including Kramer Rayson [current town attorney Tom Hale’s law firm], so I’m going to ask for the staff to start to put together the process to putting out that RFQ,” Cain said.
“Based on that, what action are you asking for the Board tonight to take on any of this?” Ruffalo asked.
“All we can do tonight is we can discuss it, and I can ask the staff to start putting that together. They can come present it to us and we’ll have to vote on it,” Cain answered.
“How would something like this affect active cases and cost of counsel changes?” Ruffalo asked.
“Somebody else would just have to take over and get up to speed,” Hale replied. “There’s no prohibition about it, and it would partly be affected, I guess, you’ve talked about cost.
“That would be part of the process of the qualifications review, part of the criteria,” he said. “And it would either be more or less the same, depending on who you picked.”
Hale has been the town’s attorney for about 29 years. He came to represent Farragut through his early work alongside the town’s original attorney, David Rodgers, who was with Kramer Rayson. When Rodgers retired in the late 1990s, Hale formally applied for the position.
Burnette questioned the need to seek qualifications from other law firms without first identifying shortcomings in the town’s current legal representation.
“Clearly, we’re not voting on anything tonight, but I just have some thoughts I’d like to throw out,” Burnette said. “I’d like for us to think what are we looking for that we don’t already have, from an experience standpoint, whether it’s municipal experience, open meetings, records, land use experience, litigation?”
Burnette also noted Board members typically turn to Hale when legal questions or issues arise.
“So, I would ask have we gone to Tom, have you gone and asked hard questions?” Burnette asked. “If you don’t get the answers, you go to the next person up, which would probably be David, and have a group meeting.
“What’s the issue that we have?” he added.
Wiberley said the review is part of a broader effort to examine town contracts.
“This isn’t a forum for evaluating past performance, but I think you’ve noticed over the past couple BOMA meetings, several of us have questioned contracts that the Town has entered into,” Wiberley said. “So, we’re reviewing lots of contracts now … we’re going to try to evaluate everything that the Town is doing to make sure your money is spent correctly.”
Cain said reviewing existing agreements is a responsibility of the Board.
Coming in as mayor, “I think it’s a natural process to look at [performance],” Cain said. “It’s part of our civic duty to look at all the different processes, contracts and agreements that we have.”
Smoak cautioned that conducting the RFQ process would require considerable staff time.
“It’s not something that’s on the staff’s program and plan for this year,” Smoak said. “It’s a lot of effort to go through a process like this. I just want to make sure there’s clear consensus from the board that this is what you want the staff to do is go through the RFQ process.”
Burnette said while the Board is questioning past town decisions, it should answer several questions before committing staff time and taxpayers’ money to the RFQ process.


