Board questions need for immediacy of CLUP update
Farragut Board of Mayor and Aldermen members were divided on whether they should update the Comprehensive Land Use Plan at this time during a workshop and the meeting that followed on Thursday, Nov. 12.
Ultimately, the Board appointed the following to the steering committee at the CLUP meeting: Farragut Municipal Planning Commission Chairman Noah Myers, Visual Resources Review Board Chairman Marty Layman, Board of Zoning Appeals Chairman Keith Alley and Parks & Athletics Council Chairman Derek Wright, as well as five citizen members, Kimberlie Parks, Phil Trewhitt, Trevor McQueen, Stacey Walters and Michael Wilson.
South Ward Alderman Drew Burnette passed on the action.
“We don’t know if we’re going to push forward with the CLUP,” he said. “I’m just wondering if we’re doing this out of order.”
North Ward Alderman Joey Ruffalo said the Board can already decide to appoint a committee and give them a task later.
Mayor Alex Cain suggested deferring the appointment to the Thursday, Dec. 10 meeting.
“I think we’re just trying to move the process along if the Board wants to move it along,” Town administrator David Smoak said.
“I know this process was done a certain way before, but I certainly would like to look at different ways of doing it this time,” Vice Mayor Greg Wiberley said during the workshop. So, “is there really a timeline to doing this plan that’s required?” he asked.
“Not a legal timeline, no,” Community Development director Mark Shipley said.
Wiberley also questioned whether the Board could continue with its existing plan.
During the meeting, North Ward Alderman Lawrence Segrest suggested waiting 12 to 18 months to concentrate on the updates.
“Farragut does not need a land use plan right now, so I’m proposing to press the pause button,” Segrest said. “What we need is traffic fixed … the TSW contract doesn’t address this.”
Wiberley suggested establishing subcommittees of that steering committee, with one subcommittee focusing on traffic.
“Volunteers are free, so why are we spending $100,000 without doing our homework ahead of time?” Wiberley asked. “At some point we get stuck, we can still call in a consultant, but why do that on the front end?”
“We need consultants to do this exact thing,” South Ward Alderman Drew Burnette said. “This is literally exactly why they exist, for towns like ours who don’t have full amenities like large cities have,” he said. “We do not have the ability to do it on our own.”
While Shipley agreed having traffic subcommittee was a good idea, he added, “I also think it’s important, as a planner, to hear thoughts on the kind of land uses people would like to see as the Town builds out.
"You have to do that in coordination with transportation.
“And, “I think it’s important to update it sooner than later because we have people who are going to be requesting rezoning,” Shipley said.
“You can’t just drag that out forever, and you do need an expert, in my opinion, to help work with staff, subcommittees and citizens.”
Former Mayor Ron Williams said postponing the CLUP update would hamstring the Town staff “if you put all of it on them at one time. You’d have to hire more people. With Mark retiring, this is going to be tough to begin with … so the land use study does need to be looked at.”
During the workshop, Shipley explained the CLUP is simply a guide, not regulatory while Town attorney Tom Hale said the state TCA 13-4-201 requires the Planning Commission to adopt a general plan in some fashion for land use.
As such, Shipley said the Town’s Comprehensive Land Use Plan is that general plan. He said it is used to help guide future growth and development.
In other action, the Board appointed Smoak as a Town representative to begin negotiations toward a settlement through legal counsel.
“The Town of Farragut has been involved in an ongoing legal dispute regarding future improvements along Turkey Creek Road,” Smoak said.
“This discussion would be for the Board of Mayor and Aldermen to select a representative.
“Any proposed settlement agreement that is potentially reached would be required to be brought back to the Board of Mayor and Aldermen to be voted upon,” he said.
The lawsuit to which he referenced concerns the Shirley Harkins property and eminent domain.


